Start with a brief that defines the audience, budget, timeline and outcome you want. Send the same brief to each prospective agency so you can compare its approach on equal terms.
Ask about comparable work
Request a case study that resembles your project. Ask what the agency actually delivered, what changed during the project and how it measured results. Look for an explanation of the baseline and how other factors were accounted for.
Compare ownership and scope
Check milestones, recurring fees and who provides each deliverable. Confirm who will own ad accounts, analytics properties and source files. Ask how access and documentation will be handed over if the relationship ends.
Start with a measurable project
Agree on acceptance criteria for an audit, pilot campaign or similar first engagement. Set a review date and use the results to decide whether the agency is a good fit for a longer contract.